What is The Substitute For Old Bay Seasoning?

Last Updated on July 19, 2022 by Tom

Substitute For Old Bay Seasoning

Layers of rich aromas combine in the Old Bay Seasoning seasoning recipe to create the iconic American spice mixture. Although this Old Bay Seasoning Recipe makes a fantastic seasoning blend, it is not a spice that is readily available. The best substitute for Old Bay seasoning in this situation is one of the choices listed below.

What is Old Bay Seasoning?

In honor of the Old Bay Line passenger ship that plied the waters of the Chesapeake Bay in the early 1900s, the Old Bay seasoning mix was developed to meet the needs of the fish industry. With its 18 different herbs and spices, Old Bay Seasoning can be used on a variety of foods, including chicken, fish, vegetables, and soups. Additionally, celery seeds, mustard, paprika, salt, red pepper, and black pepper are added.

Why Would You Want To Avoid It?

The variety of dried herbs is the only thing that will keep you from using Old Bay seasoning, which hardly ever has any negatives. You can be allergic to one of the herbs because it comprises so many different kinds. This is quite dangerous.

List Substitute For Old Bay Seasoning

Here are seven seasonings that are great picks to substitute for Old Bay seasoning.

#1. Crab boil

Boiling crab is probably the best option if you’re cooking a seafood dish with Old Bay seasoning. It is made specifically to enhance the flavors of foods like crab, lobster, shrimp, and various types of fish. Seven ingredients – cumin, all nuts, coriander seeds, cayenne pepper, bay leaf, and mustard seeds are blended with boiled crab. For a fantastic aroma, you want to preserve the seeds whole and crush them finely.

#2. Pickling spice

For everything, including stews and seafood soups, pickling spice is ideal. The Pickle Seasoning is an unusual mixture of ingredients that replicates the real flavor of Old Bay Spices, including mustard seeds, bay leaves, cilantro seeds, ginger, pepper, cloves, and cinnamon. For a more distinctive flavor, you can also add salt and celery seeds. It can be used in a 1:1 ratio in place of Old Bay Spices.

#3. Cajun seasoning

The fantastic cajun seasoning is another fantastic spice mixture that enhances the flavor profile even further. This spice has a fantastic aftertaste thanks to the mild chili spiciness. It is used to prepare any form of shrimp, steak, french fries, or another potato, whether it be grilled, smoked, or fried. 

Black pepper, dried oregano leaves, dried thyme, garlic powder, cayenne pepper, and paprika are all ingredients in this spice mixture. For the strongest Old Bay seasoning flavor, mix in some celery seeds, mustard seeds, cloves, and pepper.

#4. Chinese five-spice

The five tastes of China are available in Asian stores and can be used in place of Old Bay seasoning. It smells a lot like Old Bay because of the spice mixture of cumin, star anise, peppercorns, cloves, and cinnamon. 

The Chinese Five Flavors work well as a marinade for seafood, poultry, soups, and stews. You can add 1/2 teaspoon of celery seeds and 1/2 teaspoon each of crushed bay leaves and Chinese five spices to 1 teaspoon of Old Bay Seasoning.

#5. Salt and pepper seasoning

Old Bay tastes extremely different when combined with salt and pepper, but it tastes fantastic when combined with Chinese five spices, garlic powder, crushed red chile, ginger, salt, and pepper.

#6. Frontier seafood seasoning

This is a fantastic option for all kinds of seafood, including fish, crab, shrimp, and lobster. Celery seeds, allspice, paprika, cloves, ginger, cayenne, cardamom, mustard seeds, bay leaf, black pepper, cinnamon, and mace are all included in this mixture. You should use this spice in a 1:1 ratio since it tastes almost like Old Bay seasoning.

#7. Todd’s Chesapeake dirt

Rich spice mixture Todd’s Dirt Seasoning has various spices that taste quite similar to Old Bay Seasoning. Twenty various herbs and spices, including paprika, ground chipotle, onion powder, garlic powder, cinnamon, cloves, and ginger, are combined to create this spice. For meat meals or seafood sauces that call for a robust flavor, use this seasoning.

The Health Benefits Of Using Substitutes For Old Bay Seasoning

The finest substitute for Old Bay seasoning that has numerous health advantages is the Chinese five-spice. The majority of the five-spice powder’s constituents are warm and mildly spicy, which helps to energize the digestive system, and clean and warm the abdomen.

Szechwan navigator also has antibacterial and anti-inflammatory properties. Dry cough and sore throat symptoms can be treated with star anise. Hiccups can be cured with clove, which is also antibacterial. Cinnamon is natural diarrhea and cold and flu remedy. Finally, it aids in avoiding bloating brought on by diuretics, bloating,…

How To Make A Simple Substitute For Old Bay Seasoning That Is Healthier And Just As Delicious?

The simplest substitute for Old Bay seasoning is the Chinese five-spice. Here are some of the ingredients you’ll need and how to prepare them.

  • Navigator
  • Cinnamon
  • Clove
  • Repatriation
  • Dill

Step-by-step instructions 

1. Roast the five different kinds of ready-made components.

2. Stir thoroughly until the seeds are warm and fragrant.

3. Don’t purée the seeds until they have cooled.

4. After pulverizing all of the aforementioned components, combine them in a sizable basin.

5. After combining it, put it in a glass or plastic container with tight closure.

Recipes That Use The Substitute For Old Bay Seasoning So You Can Start Cooking Healthy Today!

Substitute for Old Bay seasoning, five-spice is used to make a variety of excellent Chinese-inspired foods. Please take a look at these delectable recipes.

1). Five-spice smoked duck with carrots and orange

You can prepare the popular restaurant meal of five-spice smoked duck with carrots and orange at home. For the finest flavor, let’s begin by heating the five spices, sweet carrots, and oranges with parsley oil. Duck flesh is smoked to give it a gorgeous pink color after being marinated with five seasonings. Even in the dead of winter, this dish tastes vibrant and fresh. See more

2). Sea bass with Chinese spice

The delicate flavor of sea bass fillet seasoned with basic fish sauce and five spices is brought out by sea bass with Chinese spices. If you want your fish to taste Japanese, you can also use dashi. Fish should be divided into small bowls for serving, with hot sauce added on top.

3). Duck with quince, endive, and candied orange

The complicated dish of duck with quince, endive, and candied orange has a deliciously sweet flavor that complements duck. Duck meat is mixed throughout with flavors of the Chinese five spices, candied orange, honey sauce, cider, endive, and quince. To give the sauce a delectable flavor and scent, orange peel is added to the meat and pork leg soup.

4). Braised beef with five-spice and star anise

With the addition of five spices, star anise, chile, and soybeans, braised beef with five-spice and star anise is a delectable dish. For the ideal family dinner, a thick sauce is applied to the steak.

6). Chinese-style barbecue ribs

Everyone will enjoy this recipe for barbecued ribs in the Chinese way. Hoisin, rice wine vinegar, ginger, garlic, and five more Chinese spices are sprinkled on top. Pork ribs are cooked to a tender, sticky, sweet, and highly seasoned consistency.

7). Char siu pork

The ideal way to enjoy this pork char siu recipe is with the extra-special char siu sauce. The roast pork is covered with the spice mixture and marinated until it becomes thick and sticky. This recipe is simple to prepare in the oven.

Some Tips To Use Old Bay Seasoning

Here are some additional uses for Old Bay seasoning aside from its well-known use as a condiment in seafood meals.

1. Add it to the corn on the cob.

2. Season popcorn and homemade potato chips with it.

3. Include it in vegetable soups with tomatoes.

4. Use it to flavor spicy sauce or cocktail sauce.

5. When dredging chicken or fish, mix it with flour.

6. Add it to mayo-based salads or deviled eggs.

7. Put it on toast with avocado.

8. Include it in the brine 

9. Season the roasted nuts with it

10. Add it to your subsequent scrambling.

11. Add it to sauces, marinades, or BBQ rubs.

12. Add some shakes to your pizza!

13. Bake some Old Bay cornbread 

14. Try it with ripe melons at number 

FAQS About Substitute For Old Bay Seasoning

Refer to the commonly asked questions below to find out the substitute for Old Bay seasoning.

  1. What are the 5 secret ingredients of the Chinese five-spice?

Star Anise, Fennel Seeds, Szechuan Peppercorns ( or regular peppercorns). Whole Cloves and Cinnamon Stick.

2. How long does spice for pickling stay fresh?

1 to 3 years

3. What function does pickling spice serve?

Pickling seasoning is a condiment added to the dish, as you would have guessed, to help the pickles contribute as much as possible to the pickling process.

4. What ingredients do pickling spices have?

Depending on what is being pickled, other aromatics, such as mustard seed, peppercorns, and bay leaves, can be added.

5. Salt is present in pickling spices?

Since pickle seasoning is essentially a mixture of several spices and herbs, it typically doesn’t contain any salt.


All of the picks to substitute for Old Bay seasoning mentioned above are excellent for daily use. They make it possible to accurately replicate the flavor of Old Bay spices and deceive even discriminating diners. Select the item that most closely matches your needs. Which product do you think is the best, then? Don’t forget to leave a comment and share your thoughts.

Give a Comment